Cameron 'overruled' Osborne's plans to impose a 'mansions tax' - leading to the creation of the 'pasty tax'
George Osborne has told MPs that his proposals to introduce a 'mansions tax' as chancellor during the coalition years collapsed - when then PM David Cameron "overruled" him.
Osborne is speaking to the Commons Treasury Committee, alongside Sir Vince Cable, ahead of the autumn budget on 26 November.
Asked about the proposal for a mansions tax and the difficulties with getting this enacted, Osborne said: "Well, the main challenge was the first lord of the Treasury [the prime minister] overruled me at the time, so it didn't happen.
"We managed to keep it a secret at the time.
"But what we had agreed, now with the passage of time, inside the coalition and between myself and my Liberal Democrat colleagues... was that we would introduce two additional bands of council tax for high valuable properties.
"I think from memory, [this would target] houses worth more than £2 million, which at the time there were 55,000 in the country, out of 24 million homes - almost all of which were in West London, it has to be said.
"Now represented by Labour MPs," said a smiling Osborne.
"But the crucial thing was," he continued. "The money raised from that was going to be used to reduce the top rate of income tax from 50p [in the pound] to 40%, where it had been throughout the Blair government.
"So, it was going to be a 50% to 40% reduction in come tax and an increased property tax to pay for it."
But as Osborne revealed, that plan was then foiled by his boss.
"I say 'overruled me'. But you know, we're still very good friends and it was never that kind of relationship.
"He made sound political arguments about why it would be a difficult thing to sell."
Osborne explained that Cameron felt the Tories had promised not to have a mansion tax and that, under pressure from Lib Dem colleagues, it was felt reducing the top income tax rate by 10% would be "too much politically".
"So, we settled on 45% and a series of small measures, including taxes on hot food [the 'pasty tax'] to pay for it", he said.
Jokingly asked if Cameron was therefore to blame for the pasty tax, Osborne responded: "Uh, not David Cameron's fault, but it's a good example of tax reform being quite hard when you're trying to raise taxes."
"Tax reform is a great thing, everyone's in favour of tax reform, but you usually create losers so it's generally easier to do tax reform when you're cutting tax, and you can kind of buy off the losers."